Buying a house is a major investment, and most buyers rely on an appraisal to ensure they are paying a fair price. But what happens when an appraisal comes back good, a person purchases the house, and later discovers the roof is bad? This scenario can be frustrating and financially challenging, leaving homeowners wondering what went wrong and what options they have.
In this article, we’ll explore why a home appraisal may overlook a bad roof, what homeowners can do if they find themselves in this situation, and how to prevent it from happening in the future.
Understanding Home Appraisals and Their Limitations
A home appraisal is an independent evaluation of a property’s value conducted by a licensed appraiser. Mortgage lenders require appraisals to ensure the home is worth the loan amount. However, an appraisal is not a home inspection and has significant limitations.
How an Appraisal Works
- The appraiser assesses the home’s condition, location, and comparable sales in the area.
- They look for visible issues that may affect the property’s value.
- The appraisal report determines whether the home’s value aligns with the asking price.
Read too: Is It Reasonable to Ask the Seller to Replace the Roof?
While appraisers may take note of obvious defects, they do not conduct a thorough roof inspection like a home inspector would. This means a home can receive a good appraisal, but still have hidden roofing problems that go unnoticed.
Appraisal Good and Person Purchases House and Roof Is Bad: Why Did This Happen?
If an appraisal was good, a person purchased the house, and later found out the roof is in bad shape, several factors could have contributed to this oversight.
1. Appraisers Focus on Property Value, Not Detailed Inspections
Appraisers are trained to determine market value, not structural integrity. They may note missing shingles or visible roof damage, but they don’t climb onto the roof or check for hidden leaks.
2. Seller May Not Have Disclosed Roof Issues
Some sellers fail to disclose roofing problems—either intentionally or because they are unaware of the issues. If a seller knew the roof was bad and didn’t disclose it, the buyer may have legal recourse.
3. The Home Inspection Was Skipped or Incomplete
Unlike an appraisal, a home inspection involves a detailed evaluation of the property’s structure, including the roof, plumbing, electrical, and foundation. If a buyer skipped the home inspection or hired an inexperienced inspector, roof problems may have gone unnoticed.
4. The Roof Looked Fine from the Outside
Some roofing issues, such as leaks, rot, and poor insulation, aren’t always visible from ground level. Even if an appraiser looked at the roof, they may not have detected underlying damage.
5. Weather Conditions May Have Hidden the Damage
If the appraisal and home purchase took place in dry weather, leaks and water damage might not have been noticeable until the first major storm.
What to Do If You Bought a House and the Roof Is Bad
Discovering a bad roof after purchasing a home can be frustrating, but there are several steps you can take to address the issue.
1. Review the Home Inspection Report (If One Was Done)
If you had a home inspection before purchasing the house, review the report to see if the inspector noted any roofing concerns. Some reports may list “roof near the end of its lifespan,” which could indicate pre-existing issues.
What to do:
- If the inspector missed obvious problems, you may be able to hold them accountable.
- Some home inspection contracts include errors and omissions insurance, which might cover the cost of repairs.
2. Check the Seller’s Disclosure Form
Most states require sellers to complete a disclosure form, listing known issues with the home, including roof problems.
What to do:
- If the seller failed to disclose known roof issues, you may have legal grounds for fraud or misrepresentation.
- Consult a real estate attorney to discuss your options.
3. Contact Your Homeowners Insurance
Some insurance policies cover unexpected roof repairs, but they usually don’t cover pre-existing conditions.
What to do:
- Check your policy for coverage details.
- If the roof was damaged by a recent storm, you may be able to file a claim for storm damage repairs.
4. Negotiate with the Seller (If Possible)
If the problem is discovered immediately after purchase, you might be able to negotiate with the seller for partial repair costs or compensation.
What to do:
- If the sale contract included a home warranty, check if the roof is covered.
- If the seller intentionally misled you, legal action might be an option.
5. Get Roofing Estimates and Plan Repairs
If you have no legal recourse, the next step is to get quotes from roofing contractors and plan the necessary repairs.
What to do:
- Compare at least three roofing estimates.
- Consider partial repairs if a full replacement is too expensive.
- If the damage is severe, look into roof financing options.
How to Avoid Buying a House with a Bad Roof in the Future
If you’re in the market for a home, here are key steps to avoid getting stuck with a bad roof:
1. Always Get a Professional Home Inspection
Never rely solely on an appraisal. A home inspection is essential to uncover hidden issues.
2. Ask About the Roof’s Age and Condition
During the buying process, ask the seller:
- How old is the roof? (Roofs typically last 20-30 years.)
- Have there been any repairs or leaks?
- Is there a transferable roof warranty?
3. Request a Roof Certification
A roof certification is a separate inspection conducted by a roofing contractor to assess the roof’s condition and lifespan. Some sellers may provide this as part of the sale.
4. Look for Signs of Roof Damage
Even without an inspector, you can check for red flags:
- Water stains on ceilings (indicating leaks).
- Missing or curling shingles.
- Sagging roof sections.
5. Negotiate Repairs Before Closing
If the home inspection reveals roofing issues, negotiate with the seller to:
- Lower the sale price to cover repair costs.
- Have the seller fix the roof before closing.
Conclusion
The situation where an appraisal is good, a person purchases the house, and the roof is bad is more common than many homebuyers realize. Because appraisals focus on home value rather than structural integrity, roofing issues can be missed, leaving buyers with unexpected repair costs.
To avoid this problem, a thorough home inspection, direct questions about the roof, and proactive negotiations are crucial before finalizing a home purchase. If you find yourself dealing with a bad roof after buying a home, reviewing the inspection report, seller disclosures, and insurance options can help determine your next steps.
Being informed and prepared can save you thousands of dollars and prevent buyer’s remorse when investing in a home.
Leave a Reply